Ethox and WEH Seminar: What gives them the right? Legal privilege and waivers of consent for research
Jon Merz, Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania
Thursday, 20 September 2018, 11am to 12.30pm
Seminar Room 0, Big Data Institute, University of Oxford Old Road Campus, OX3 7FZ
ABSTRACT
Waivers of informed consent for research participation are permitted in the United States under the Common Rule, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act regulations, and the FDA's Exception from Informed Consent (EFIC) rule for emergency research. We assess the novel question regarding what legal right researchers have to carry out research procedures on or about another person, be it experimental medical intervention, psychological or social manipulation, or invasion of privacy, without the permission of their subjects. Our analysis frames waivers of consent as a species of presumed consent, and we address the underlying empirical question of whether it is reasonable to believe that subjects from whom no consent is sought would in fact agree, if asked. A scoping review of what is known about participation and refusal rates in US-based research suggests that a large minority, on average, do not agree to take part in research. Refusal rates vary widely. This suggests that, while researchers may assert the social utility of their studies are high enough to justify waivers, there is reason to suspect that many who would be enrolled under a waiver of consent would not want to be enrolled. We conclude that waivers should be rare, and that IRBs and researchers must explicitly address study acceptability in the community at large and the target population of their proposed research.
VIEW Previous Richard Doll seminars IN Public health and epidemiology
Professor Sir Richard Doll
Forthcoming events
Contemporary Trends in Cardiovascular Disease and Obesity: Insights from Whole-Population Electronic Health Records in England
Tuesday, 27 May 2025, 1pm to 2pm @ Richard Doll lecture theatre
Will the next pandemic be caused by H5N1 influenza?
Monday, 02 June 2025, 1pm to 2pm @ Richard Doll Lecture Theatre
The world is currently experiencing a panzootic of H5N1 influenza. Wild birds have carried the virus across all continents and an unprecedented number of mammalian species have been infected including humans. What will it take for this virus to go pandemic, and does the introduction of the virus into dairy herds in USA bring that one step closer? Wendy will discuss the current knowledge on host range barriers that protect us from more frequent zoonoses and pandemic from bird flu, and show how we can use this scientific knowledge to risk assess the current situation.
Trials and tribulations: streamlining large randomized trials to answer important cardiometabolic questions
Tuesday, 03 June 2025, 1pm to 2pm @ Richard Doll lecture theatre
Better treatment for tuberculosis
Monday, 09 June 2025, 1pm to 2pm @ BDI/OxPop Building LG seminar rooms
Resolving the genetic basis of type 2 diabetes in 125 000 Mexicans
Tuesday, 10 June 2025, 1pm to 2pm @ Richard Doll Lecture Theatre
The burden of drug resistant infections, the GRAM project
Monday, 16 June 2025, 1pm to 2pm @ BDI/OxPop Building LG seminar rooms